The world has woken up to ethical issues in corporate governance & accounting practices. Corporate heads that were not guillotined were forced hang their heads in retrospective shame. The heads that fell were the victimizers, and the axe that fell, fell too late, and the punishment received, was way too little compared to the suffering, pain and financial losses that the organizations' stakeholders suffered. Trust of millions of investors was lost overnight.
Ethics in governance is one part of the story, the other link in this dubious chain of deceit is usually the professional services like auditing, legal and public relations which work closely with the organization. Such large scale deceit becomes possible only with the active collaboration of these so-called 'professional' services. Hardly professional, really!
The Indian investor has been victim to a lot of companies attempting to make a quick buck in the markets. While caveat emptor ? let the buyer beware, is the legal term that organizations to get out of such wrangles, it is necessary to look into how these various scams are done, and to recognize the role of the professional services, especially public relations in creating and sustaining the scams.
Circa 1994. Every Indian remembers the bloody battlefield of the stock markets. While the aftereffects are well embedded in everyone's memory, few remember how it all began. Upbeat stock stories in the newspapers, stories of millions being made overnight, the oldest stock exchange of the country celebrating the index at an unprecedented high. Stock market pages kept the upward arrow next to almost every stock price quoted indicating the trends. Investors scrambled, dinner conversation revolved around the stock prices, 21 year olds were sitting in front of red-blue flashing computer screens, buying and selling tens of thousands of shares in seconds.
While some companies were actually performing well, many slipped through the back-door and slipped up their shares to unwary investors. Why is the investor so gullible? And is the investor really so gullible?
The method that was used to market the fly-by-night companies to the investors combined the well-used public relations concepts of fear, uncertainty and doubt (FUD). Successful FUD pushes to show how you would be the only person who would be left in the race if you did not buy-in into the campaigner's concept, creates uncertainty about your own analysis & gut-feel and generates doubt about the products or services currently under use. This especially works wonders in a greed-struck stock market, where more often than not, mob-psychology rather than knowledge is the deciding factor.
Usually such scams are orchestrated in connivance with some unscrupulous public relations companies. At other times, the PR companies usually have enough pointers to the possibility of such a scam about to take place. Press conferences are called, headlines blare out the superlative performances of the organization, there is talk of new acquisitions, investor meets happen and stock analysts are shown the factory, the plush office to generate confidence in the investor. The PR agency is rewarded for its great 'efforts' by way of a few millions and the investors collective gets duped for a few billions. Case studies of this century in such dubious PR in India would include the CRB scam, MS Shoes, Harshad Mehta & Home Trade fiasco. While these are the few stories which come to light, there are many scams which get away without even getting noticed.
What is the responsibility of the public relations company in such circumstances? The agency must evaluate the client and understand program and take a view that is beyond just the fees that it will generate and take a responsible decision. The PR agency can & must become the watch-dog for the companies, advising them, guiding them and if nothing prevails, then going to the extent of resigning the account for of a larger good. This kind of discussion, though popular conversation in PR cocktail circuits, is still eschewed by the PR intellectuals in more serious forums!
Unless we work as a committed community on the principles that should guide the PR business; and take stringent action against those who use these tools-of-influence to feed their greed, the respectable business of PR will go to the depths of unrecoverable ignominy very soon.
Chandramouli is the CEO of Blue Lotus Communications Consultancy, a leading knowledge based public relations agency located in Mumbai,India. He is an Engineer-MBA with over 16 years of multi-functional experience and has guided Blue Lotus to a core focus in the booming sectors of Healthcare, Finance, Education and Technology.
Wherever the fundamental premise of public relations is practiced.Look at... Read More
Everyone knows the value of free publicity. And given the... Read More
While scoring anice story in BusinessWeek or USA Today is... Read More
So many restaurants spend money on publicity and then practically... Read More
The power of PassionPassion is an extraordinarily powerful spring. Without... Read More
As a business, non-profit or association manager, let the tacticians... Read More
Public relations writing when writing press releases can be a... Read More
If a reporter was writing a story about you and... Read More
I've worked in media and public relations for 20 years,... Read More
I got the latest issue of Internet Works in the... Read More
The short answer is, it works best when its fundamental... Read More
What may be the more appropriate question is: What makes... Read More
Imagine you're the technology reporter at a daily newspaper. You... Read More
Press releases are a useful tool for announcing news and... Read More
More than half of America skips the Super Bowl, the... Read More
Especially good advice for business, non-profit and association managers whose... Read More
Do editors of newspapers, magazines and online news sites really... Read More
A reporter's job is to get the most accurate and... Read More
And show it for what it is - a humdinger... Read More
The reason might be this simple: as a business, non-profit... Read More
It's a phrase I hear over and over again from... Read More
It happens to business, non-profit and association managers when their... Read More
When your book is mentioned on television, sales go up.... Read More
For financial planners, getting publicity, in the end, isn't about... Read More
What is the true purpose of public relations and how... Read More
Attention: Who Else Wants To Get Publicity Whenever You Want... Read More
Yes, and that pressure often comes from a CEO who... Read More
Think that you aren't big enough for national media coverage?... Read More
Yes? Then do something positive about the behaviors of those... Read More
As a business, non-profit or association manager, you have a... Read More
Imagine you're the technology reporter at a daily newspaper. You... Read More
SORRY?WERE YOU SAYING SOMETHING?Many spokespeople approach media interviews the same... Read More
Media kits include a combination of information whether created for... Read More
As the year starts to wind down, many businesses and... Read More
As eyes look forward to a new business year, many... Read More
Unlike some professionals like lawyers and doctors, financial planners aren't... Read More
Recently, I told a friend (who's a business owner) that... Read More
The fast changing dynamics of the world economy is forcing... Read More
When your book is mentioned on television, sales go up.... Read More
Be a ResourceThe media people that are likely to want... Read More
The Internet may have opened worlds for businesses and consumers,... Read More
You won't accomplish much if you call the gas company... Read More
Although it seems less common these days, there are still... Read More
A few weeks ago I was participating on an on-line... Read More
When it comes to launching a new business or product,... Read More
What's the real reason some managers shy away from public... Read More
If I were coaching you as a business, non-profit or... Read More
Media management has become one of the strategic tools for... Read More
Some financial planners think that they shouldn't share their top... Read More
News releases are not the best way to get major... Read More
Public Relations |