President Bush's selection of the Hon. John Roberts is an interesting choice. The betting, and there had been betting, was on a minority or female candidate. Instead, President Bush swings for the fences with a middle-aged, white male. Let the ugliness begin.
Competency
Regardless of your political views, Roberts' intellectual competency cannot be questioned. This man was a very competent lawyer and is a thoughtful judge. As an advocate, his arguments before the Supreme Court were always creative and thorough. As a judge, his written opinions reveal sound analytical skills and logical interpretations of the facts at hand.
The current court constituency has been together for far too long and is intellectually vacant on many issues. The leading intellectuals, Rehnquist and O'Connor are the undisputed "thinkers" on the court. Obviously, O'Connor is gone and Rehnquist will undoubtedly take a reduced roll in light of his serious health issues. The poor man looks like hell!
Of the remaining justices, none is particularly sharp and certainly not a leader of the court. Scalia is a publicity hound and hurls insults at all who disagree with him. Thomas issues opinions that nearly everyone agrees are simply bizarre. Stevens has always taken a back seat and Ginsburg certainly will be in the minority. The remaining Justices are often wildly inconsistent and certainly have issued a number of opinions that turn on the most inane of facts. The recent contradictory decisions regarding the 10 Commandments are perfect examples of a Court gone adrift.
If confirmed, John Roberts will be the first step in bringing solid legal reasoning back to the bench. By solid, I don't mean liberal or conservative thinking. I simply mean decisions that are logically consistent. Of all the current Justices, Roberts would clearly be the best choice for Chief Justice when Rehnquist finally leaves the bench. .
Okay, we've established Robert's is a quality judge. What effect will his confirmation have on the landmark decisions, particularly Roe v. Wade?
Landmark Decisions
Make no mistake, John Roberts is very conservative. Generally, he will side with the conservatives on the bench, but not always. His vote will be critical since he is replacing Justice O'Connor, the historical swing voter. Depending upon your political leanings, this as either a good or bad thing.
Roe v. Wade
Will Roe v. Wade be overturned? This is the key to Roberts' tenure on the bench. Personally, his conservative leanings would suggest Roe is dead in the water, but not so fast. Roberts also has a strong belief in upholding landmark cases that have set precedent for an area of law. Obviously, Roe is such a case. Nobody can predict what he will do, but we can predict that the choice will shape his future on the bench.
If Roberts votes to overturn Roe, we will see a complete re-writing of all the landmark cases. By voting to overturn, Roberts will position himself solidly with the conservative Justices on the court. Everything will be open game and the legal landscape will change dramatically.
If Roberts votes to uphold Roe, you can expect the conservative Justices to remain the minority for the foreseeable future. This prediction has everything to do with Justice Scalia.
Although championed by conservative groups, those in legal circles know that no single person has been a bigger obstacle for the conservative movement on the bench. The problem, quite simply, is Scalia is a jerk. He has a very bad habit of personally attacking other Justices in written opinions when they don't agree with him. Justices O'Connor, Kennedy and Sauter were all supposed to be conservatives, but became moderates on the bench. The generally agreed cause is the personal attacks Scalia let fly in his dissents. Kennedy, in particular, is known to bristle at the mention of Scalia. Though they issue denials, it is well known that many Justices are not on speaking terms with Scalia. If you would like to learn more on the division, pick up a copy of "A Court Divided: The Rehnquist Court and the Future of Constitutional Law."
If Scalia personally attacks Roberts in written opinions, human nature suggests Roberts will move towards the middle. Scalia will do just such a thing should Roberts vote to uphold Roe. In short, it all comes down to Roberts' decision on Roe v. Wade.
One way or another, the Supreme Court is about to come front and center in the public eye. Within the next five years, we should see at least two more Justices, Rehnquist and Stevens, leave the bench. Once they retire, the court should remain stable for at least ten years. If only we knew how they would rule!
Richard Chapo is with http://www.sandiegobusinesslawfirm.com - a firm providing legal advice to California businesses. Visit http://www.sandiegobusinesslawfirm.com to read more legal articles.
Chicago limo Skokie ..The evacuation of Gaza is now completed, and the world... Read More
We are slowing the transportation flows of our civilization by... Read More
The second amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees every American... Read More
I'm starting to feel squeezed by all the political correctness... Read More
Last year a Maryland State Legislator whom I presume never... Read More
As of late steroid use in sports has been the... Read More
I've been thinking again. I know some of my readers... Read More
We have seen an increase in Snowbirds from Northern States... Read More
Possible UAV materials are infinite: Foam, Composite, Balsa Wood, Plastic,... Read More
Corporate America has been shaken recently by lawsuits and criminal... Read More
We need more oversight and transparency in government. We need... Read More
In the future when we decide to help nations vote... Read More
One question not addressed in GM Crops and Monsanto Terminator... Read More
According to a postulate made by Ignacio Ramonet ecological resources... Read More
Those who are above the law or act as such... Read More
Do you really want to get ahead in your life?... Read More
The recent scathing remarks by High Court Judge Richard Mawrey... Read More
The Palestinian Fatah Movement is doing whatever it can to... Read More
Blessed with Chinese GDP growth rates (7-8% annually in each... Read More
A War on Terrorism? Conventional war being brought on an... Read More
This is the third in a short series of four... Read More
-The Protocol plan 'will remain invisible until the moment when... Read More
While many Pennsylvanians are struggling to figure out how they... Read More
I watch the TV news and I get angry. I... Read More
The official working week is being reduced to 35 hours... Read More
limo O'Hare Bonfield ..One of Abraham Lincoln's claims to fame is the fact... Read More
Clint Eastwood recently plunged into the murky political pond with... Read More
The Jihad against the Western World will continue. It will... Read More
Aren't you glad you purchased Alaska? You got a bargain,... Read More
As more and more cities and states set up websites... Read More
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act Was created on July 30th 2002, by... Read More
Non-lethal Goo Concepts have been tossed around by many war... Read More
We can all see the issues involved in the cloning... Read More
This is the third in a short series of four... Read More
Policemen in many US cities are taking their new authority... Read More
When you look at the news, immigrants are dying trying... Read More
The organic farmers are angry that Monsantos terminator GM seeds... Read More
Do you ever wonder how everything gets to the super... Read More
Contrary to the Hobbesian prediction of anarchy (freedom) and brutish... Read More
With the recent threats from Bin Laden and Al Queda... Read More
Have you noticed that the when the service men who... Read More
Prison guards and corrections professionals are hard at work insuring... Read More
Perhaps a silent revolution is taking place, this time more... Read More
As you know Delta Airlines is close to bankruptcy. Their... Read More
Roberto Calvo Macias, a young author and thinker from Spain,... Read More
On June 16, 1972, a security guard at the Watergate... Read More
From the comfort of their plush offices and five to... Read More
Heavens, what are we up against? It seems these days... Read More
In discussing the OODA Loop theory on Limited War by... Read More
We have read about the unemployment rate being high. Really... Read More
Political |